Book Review: An Amish Homecoming

In the early 16th century, religious reformation swept through Europe. The schism between the Catholic Church and those protesting its overreach and corruption gave birth to Protestantism. Because of differences of opinion and interpretation of scripture, several Protestant sects emerged. One group was the Anabaptists, who believe that to be baptized, a person must first confess his/her faith in Christ. (For this reason, Anabaptists do not believe in christening infants.) From these Anabaptists came three “plain” communities: Amish, Mennonites, and Brethren with Amish being the most conservative.

Starting in the early 1700s, many Anabaptists immigrated to the Americas. In both my and my spouse’s family trees are individuals who practiced (or still practice) these Anabaptist faiths. It is because of my ancestral connection to these religions that I decided to venture beyond my historical fiction “comfort zone” and explore a new genre: contemporary Amish fiction.

I determined that the best way to begin was by sampling the works of several established authors, which is why I chose An Amish Homecoming: Four Stories.

The first novella, No Place Like Home, by Amy Clipston, introduces Eva Diemmer, whose husband has perished in a fire. For her young son’s sake, Eva reaches out to her parents to repair the rift her marriage and moving away has caused.

The second novella, When Love Returns, by Beth Wiseman, begins with single mother Sarah Zook trying to pick up the pieces of her life after Hurricane Harvey. With nothing left except a few meager belongings, Sarah and her child head home to her parents with whom she has not spoken in six years.

The third novella, The Courage to Love, by Shelley Shepard Gray, introduces Irene Keim, whose life has been one of heartache. Unloved as a child, Irene is taken in by a kindly couple who cherish her for whom she is. Unfortunately, their son is not nearly as welcoming.

The final novella, What Love Built, by Kathleen Fuller, tells the story of widower Atlee Shetler, who, after 12 years, still grieves for his wife, and spinster Carolyn Yoder, who, after 10 years away, has returned home to open a bakery. Both Atlee and Carolyn soon realize that in order to step into a bright and hopeful future, they must first deal with the pain of their pasts.

In each of these stories, I felt immersed in the characters’ lives, vicariously experiencing their internal conflicts. However, until these characters give and/or accept forgiveness, challenge assumptions, or open their hearts to others, they cannot move forward.

Although the stories contained in An Amish Homecoming are engaging and easy-to-read, I found it strange to see Pennsylvania Deutsche words interspersed throughout the text. Yes, the characters are mostly conversing with each other in their native language. But, since these novellas are written for a native English audience, it seemed silly to me to insert a German word here or there just for effect. Although I comprehend the German language, every time a danke, gut, nee, mei, etc. appeared in the dialogue, it just felt a bit off to me.

Other than that, I enjoyed reading these stories and would recommend contemporary Amish fiction to anyone who enjoys sweet romances or Christian-centric writing.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Zondervan through Booklook Bloggers. Opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.

Categories: Book Reviews | Tags: , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Post navigation

One thought on “Book Review: An Amish Homecoming

  1. Thank you for this review – it sounds like a book I’d enjoy (if I can only get through my current stack of TBRs)!

    Liked by 1 person

Please share your thoughts...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a website or blog at

Sheila's Archive

A Family History

Anna's Musings & Writings

A Catholic and Aspiring Contemplative's Journey, Genealogy, Odds and Ends . . .

Rhos Helyg Family History Services

Follow my family history adventures and more

Personal Prologue: Family Roots and Personal Branches

Copyright©2021, Margo Lee Williams, All Rights Reserved

Once Upon A Lifetime: Tales And Vignettes Of My Ancestors

MaryAnne Slabik-Haffner, Family History Author

Rhyme Schemes and Daydreams

Things That Interest Me

The Chiddicks Family Tree

Every Family has a story to tell..........Welcome to mine

writing my past

in which I document my genealogical research adventures and explore the people and events from my family's history…

Deeper Roots Genealogy

~ Discovering Your Family's Past To Shape Your Future ~

Delving into the past

Here you shall find, my writings, about my family research, and general research into murders, and other people's ancestry, where I dig deep, and find all kinds of information about my family, whether it is good or bad, and my life itself in general, there are some sad, informative, facts here, which I hope, will get you guys blogging, so what are you waiting for? Get reading!

A Pennsylvania Dutch Genealogy

the genealogy & family research site of Kris Hocker

The Family Letter Blog

Connecting Generations

Discovering Yesterday

Preserving the history of ordinary people

Barb's GeNealogy Life

Combining two of my favorite addictive pastimes - family history and writing.

Past Presence

A site for genealogists and family historians

Julie's Genealogy & History Hub

Blog of Brass Oak Genealogy

The Family Kalamazoo

A genealogical site devoted to the history of the DeKorn and Zuidweg families of Kalamazoo and the Mulder family of Caledonia

From Shepherds and Shoemakers

Sharing musings, insights, resources and strategies as I discover my family history.

Its good to be crazy Sometimes

A view from the inside of going through the minefield of the British benefit system if you are disabled and the ups and downs of coping with mental illness


Words of wisdom, inspiration, feeling

Rants, Rambles, Revelations, Remembrances

Because the voice in my head won't stay silent...

Genealogy for Children

How to engage children in genealogy and family history

Brumley Family Branches

A Genealogy Blog


Collecting stories from family historians who are climbing their family trees and planning trips to where their ancestors actually lived!

Kindred Stories

Everyone has a story


Where Distant Family Become Close

Jill's Garden

Garden of Life

Chips Off the Old Block

A blog devoted to genealogical wanderings - dedicated to family near and far, through distance and time

Applegate Genealogy

Helping others discover their roots

Gary A Wilson Stories

10 Minute Adventures, Fiction and Coffee Breaks

Shaking The Branches

Sharing Stories From My Family Tree

Decoding the Family Tree

solving family history one branch at a time.

Bespoke Genealogy

UK and Ireland: Genealogy, History and Travel

The Letters

Louise Mabey

From Ballachulish to South Mississippi

Mississippi family history letters


Exploring the Past to Improve the Future

Aquila's Place

An Eccentric Mix of Literature and Opinions

The Women Who Made Me

Finding the extraordinary in the ordinary

F Yeah History

History...but better

Amanda Bradburn

Author | Editor | Genealogist | Historian


Actor, Writer, and Embroidery Artist seeking beauty and humour.

Today in History

"Tell me a fact, and I'll learn. Tell me a truth, and I'll believe. But tell me a story, and it will live in my heart forever." - Steve Sabol, NFL Films

Empty Branches on the Family Tree

Genealogy Tips & Family History

Dusty Roots & Forgotten Treasures

Researching, Preserving, and Sharing Genealogical Information For Future Generations

%d bloggers like this: